No no, keep reading! I swear this is SO. EASY, and will be the tangiest, most tender mozzarella cheese that you’ve ever tasted. SERIOUSLY!
To make your own mozzarella, there are two ingredients you’ll need that you may not be as familiar with or have in your kitchen regularly…
- Citric acid: I was able to grab this at a Middle Eastern market down the street from me, but you can usually find it near the canning supplies at supermarkets or hardware stores.
- Rennet: I found this at my regular grocery store in the refrigerated section alongside other yogurt making supplies. There are beef and chicken-based rennets but I used the vegetarian one.
DIY Mozzarella Cheese Ingredients & Supplies
Note: We prefer to shop locally or use what we have at home, but this list contains a few Amazon affiliate links for reference. As Amazon Associates we make a small commission on qualifying purchases.*
- A Food thermometer
- A Colander
- Cheesecloth (like this kind)
*Note: At the end of the process, you will be handling extremely hot cheese. It’s a good idea to have a clean pair of kitchen gloves ready to go in case you have sensitive fingertips.
DIY Mozzarella Cheese Instructions:
- Prepare your citric acid and rennet solutions
Add 1 1/2 teaspoon citric acid to 1 cup cool water in small bowl. In a seperate small bowl, combine 1/4 teaspoon rennet (or 1.4 tab) and 1/4 cup cool water.
- Combine the milk and citric acid & water mixture in a pot
Pour milk into pot, add citric acid/water mixture to milk and stir.
Heat milk slowly to 90 degrees (being careful not to burn the milk).
- Add rennet and water mixture
Remove pot from heat and add rennet/water mixture and stir through for 30 seconds. Cover and leave for 5 minutes. Check the curds – they should be white and the whey should be clear.
- Squeeze excess water from curds
Spoon the curd into a cheesecloth-lined colander and allow to drain. Once the excess water has drained, gather into a ball, and squeeze out any remaining water. Remove from the cheesecloth and transfer curds to a bowl.
- Microwave and knead until taffy-like
Microwave the curds for one minute, then pour off the whey. Knead and re-microwave for another 30 seconds. You’ll want to knead curd as though you would bread dough and re-microwave for 30 seconds as needed. It will soon begin to stretch like taffy.
- Season and form
Once you’re able to stretch your mozzarella, salt to taste and form your mozzarella into a ball (or quite a few smaller balls for easy snacking, as I did).
- Serve warm or refrigerate in cold water
Serve warm or put in a bowl of cold water in the fridge. FYI: your mozzarella will lose shape if you don’t put it in some sort of form or handle it until it’s completely cool, so I recommend having a bowl of cold water at-the-ready.
Once finished your mozzarella should look similar to the balls I made below – don’t you just want to dig right in?!
Simple DIY mozzarella snacks for kids
One of the things I love about making our own DIY mozzarella is that it’s so incredibly easy to grab a little protein-packed snack that I know is super fresh, has zero added preservatives or questionable ingredients, and was made by hand – by me!
My favorite way to snack on our homemade moz is to combine it with fresh tomatoes, basil, balsamic, and toast for a delightfully yummy bruschetta (this recipe from Cookie + Kate is my go-to!) Here are a few more fun ways to prepare snacks for (or with) your kiddos in the kitchen…
- Need a healthy school or party snack in a hurry? Cut your mozzarella ball into bite-sized pieces and toss in a cup along with fresh-cut tomato, black olives, a basil leaf, and a small drizzle of olive oil. Buono! A mini on-the-go Caprese salad! You could also make them into kebabs like these tomato and mozzarella bites from America’s Test Kitchen)
- Make a refreshing and summer salad your little ones can eat with their hands by cutting up watermelon, tossing in some mozzarella bites, and sprinkling with some fresh chopped mint.
- Baked Whole Grain Mozzarella Sticks from Super Healthy Kids
- Mini Margherita Pizzas from Better Homes & Gardens
- Simple Pasta Caprese from Kidstir
- Grilled Pesto & Mozzarella Cheese Sandwiches from Simply Scratch
*A note about Amazon affiliate links: We strive to use simple, earth-friendly supplies that can be purchased locally whenever we can, but sometimes we find the best universally available options, a rare eco-friendly find, or a niche product only available on Amazon. When included in our supply list, these products are affiliate links, and if you click-through to make a purchase, we receive a small commission that helps us re-order these supplies!